Series rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Books Include:
Likes:
- Slow burn romances.
- Quiet little English town.
- J.L. Merrow’s writing style.
- Some incredibly quirky characters.
- Some really great kids.
- Very little homophobia (and what little there was got overcome in the end).
- The English slang.
- Blue collar workers who were proud of their jobs.
Dislikes:
- Sex scenes were short, not too steamy, and at the end of the books.
- Some similarities in the types of couples.
To be fair to Out! I did like all the books in this series. The quiet, slow atmosphere of Shamwell was just what I was looking for, but I can see why some people thought it was too slow and boring. This is not a series where a lot of things happen. All of the drama comes either from miscommunication (or no communication at all) or everyday outside forces.
I really liked the English slang in the book, even thought I didn’t know some of it, because it made the books very atmospheric. Shamwell really did become like a subtle character of its own in a lot of little ways. The people who lived there were very simple, in a good way, while the ones who moved there were all on the flamboyant side.
This brings me to the similarities between the books. In each one, one of the two main characters has just moved to town. All the newcomers are well-educated and come from wealthy families or are well off themselves. Their love interests are blue collar working men, except Patrick who works for a non-profit, which is not a high paying job. The men from Shamwell are generally more connected to their families than the men who have just moved there.
Despite these similarities, each of the couples was very different from the others, both in terms of the problems they face and how they interact with each other. I enjoyed reading about all of the couples and nothing glaringly wrong pulled me out of any of the stories.
Out! was my least favorite not because anything was wrong with it but because Patrick and Mark were both less flamboyant characters than the other couples. Rob, David, and Tristan were all fabulous characters with fun, memorable quirks. I donโt think Patrick or Mark was boring per se, but compared to the fabulous three, they didn’t stand out as much. Fen and Lex stood out more.
Overall, I could have happily read more books in this series. It was cute and low angst and I’m really glad I picked it up. Caught! Was the first book I’ve ever ready by J.L. Merrow and I will definitely pick up something else she’s written.



